Living in Florida means accepting that our homes will face some unique challenges, from seasonal hurricanes to sudden, intense thunderstorms. It’s part of the trade-off for living in paradise. Because our weather patterns can be so unpredictable, being prepared is not just a good idea—it’s essential. A key part of that preparation is understanding how these events translate into real-world damage. Looking into what are the most common home insurance claims filed in our state gives you a practical roadmap of what to expect and how to protect your property from the most frequent and costly types of damage we see year after year.

Key Takeaways

• Prevention is your best policy: Simple, routine checks on your plumbing, roof, and fire safety systems can help you avoid the most common types of property damage and the hassle of filing a claim.
• Understand your coverage before a crisis hits: Your standard policy likely has exclusions, such as flood damage, and limits on valuables. Reviewing your documents now helps you identify and fill any gaps in protection before you actually need to file a claim.
• Build a strong claim through documentation and advocacy: After damage occurs, your best move is to take detailed photos and get independent repair estimates. This evidence puts you in a stronger position to negotiate a fair settlement with your insurer.

What Are the Most Common Home Insurance Claims?

When you own a home, dealing with property damage is often a matter of when, not if. Understanding the most common types of insurance claims can help you prepare for potential issues and know what to look for in your policy. From storm damage to unexpected accidents, certain problems pop up more frequently than others for homeowners. Knowing what you might face is the first step in protecting your biggest investment. Here’s a look at the five most common claims property owners file, which can give you a clearer picture of the risks involved.

Wind and Hail Damage

Living in Florida, we’re no strangers to intense weather. It’s probably no surprise that wind and hail damage is the single most common type of home insurance claim, accounting for over 40% of all claims filed. This category covers everything from shingles torn off by a hurricane to siding dented by hail. The average claim for this type of damage runs over $13,000, a significant expense for any homeowner. After a major storm, it’s crucial to inspect your roof, windows, and exterior. If you find damage, documenting it thoroughly is key to a successful claim. An experienced public adjuster can be a valuable ally in making sure your assessment is complete and fair.

Water and Freezing Damage

Water damage is another incredibly common issue, making up nearly 28% of home insurance claims. While burst pipes from freezing are less of a concern in our warmer climate, issues like leaking appliances, overflowing toilets, and broken water heaters are frequent culprits. These incidents can cause extensive damage not just to your floors and walls but can also lead to mold if not addressed quickly. The average claim for water damage is almost $14,000. It’s a sneaky problem that can escalate fast, so acting immediately to stop the source of the water and begin the cleanup process is essential for protecting your property and your health.

Fire and Lightning Damage

While less frequent than wind or water issues, fire and lightning claims are by far the most devastating and expensive. These claims account for about 22% of the total but come with an average cost of nearly $84,000. A fire can destroy not only the structure of your home but also all your personal belongings, creating a total loss scenario. In Florida, lightning strikes are also a common cause of house fires. The emotional and financial toll of a fire is immense, and handling the complex claims process afterward can be overwhelming. Getting expert help to document your losses and negotiate with your insurer can make a world of difference during such a difficult time.

Liability Claims

Liability claims happen when someone is injured on your property, and you are found legally responsible. Think of a guest slipping on a wet floor or a delivery person tripping on a broken step. While these claims are relatively rare, making up less than 2% of all claims, they are quite costly, with an average payout of over $31,000. Your homeowners insurance typically includes liability coverage to protect you from these situations, covering medical bills and legal fees. Maintaining a safe property is the best prevention, so regularly checking for and fixing potential hazards like loose railings or uneven walkways is always a smart move.

Theft and Burglary

The thought of someone breaking into your home is unsettling, and unfortunately, it does happen. Theft accounts for less than 1% of all homeowners insurance claims, making it the least common on this list. The average claim for stolen items is just over $5,000. This coverage helps you replace personal belongings that are taken from your home, from electronics and jewelry to furniture. While the financial reimbursement is helpful, the peace of mind that comes from having a secure home is priceless. Investing in a good security system, sturdy locks, and proper lighting can deter potential intruders and help you feel safer.

Common Myths About Insurance Claims

Insurance policies can feel like they’re written in another language. It’s easy to make assumptions about what your coverage includes, but those misunderstandings can leave you in a tough spot when you actually need to file a claim. Believing your policy is a catch-all safety net is one of the most common and costly mistakes a homeowner can make. The reality is that every policy has fine print, with specific limits and exclusions that define exactly what your insurer will and won’t pay for. These details are what separate a smooth claims process from a frustrating denial.

Let’s clear up some of the confusion. By understanding what your policy truly covers, you can make sure you have the right protection in place before a disaster happens. We’re going to walk through five of the most persistent myths about home insurance claims. Getting familiar with these truths will help you feel more confident about your coverage and better prepared to handle the unexpected. It’s about moving from hoping you’re covered to knowing you’re covered, which makes all the difference when you’re facing property damage.

Myth: My Policy Covers Everything

It’s a comforting thought, but unfortunately, it’s not true. Many homeowners are surprised to learn that their standard policy has a list of exclusions. For example, while damage from a burst pipe might be covered, gradual damage from a slow leak you didn’t fix may not be. These policies are designed to cover sudden and accidental events, not issues stemming from a lack of maintenance. It’s important to read your policy documents carefully to understand these limitations and avoid being caught off guard. There are many common home insurance myths that can cost you.

Myth: I’m Covered for All Natural Disasters

This is a critical misunderstanding, especially for those of us in Florida. Most standard home insurance policies do not cover damage from floods, earthquakes, or sinkholes. These events typically require separate, specialized insurance policies or add-ons, known as endorsements. With hurricane season being a regular concern, it’s essential to confirm whether you have adequate flood insurance, as this is almost always a separate purchase from your primary homeowner’s policy. Don’t wait until a storm is on the way to find out you’re not protected.

Myth: All My Belongings Are Protected

Your homeowner’s policy does include coverage for your personal belongings, but there are usually limits. Insurers often place a cap on the total value they will pay out for certain categories of high-value items, like jewelry, art, firearms, or collectibles. If the value of your collection exceeds your policy’s sub-limit (which could be as low as $1,500 for jewelry), you won’t be fully reimbursed for a loss. To properly protect these items, you may need to purchase an additional endorsement or a separate policy called a “personal article floater.”

Myth: Filing a Claim Won’t Affect My Rates

While you pay your premiums for this exact reason, filing a claim can sometimes impact your insurance rates upon renewal. Insurance companies assess risk, and a history of claims can signal to them that your property is a higher risk to insure. A single, minor claim might not have a significant effect, but multiple claims in a short period or a particularly large claim could lead to higher premiums. This doesn’t mean you shouldn’t file a legitimate claim, but it’s a factor to consider, especially for smaller issues you might be able to handle out of pocket.

Myth: My Home Business Is Covered

With the rise of remote work and home-based businesses, this myth is more relevant than ever. Your standard homeowner’s policy provides very little, if any, coverage for business-related activities. It typically won’t cover business equipment, inventory stored in your home, or liability if a client is injured on your property. If you run a home-based business, you will likely need a separate business insurance policy to ensure you have the right liability and property protection.

What Does Your Policy Actually Cover?

It’s easy to assume your homeowners insurance is a catch-all safety net, but policies have specific limits and exclusions. Understanding what’s covered before you need to file a claim can save you a lot of headaches. Think of your policy as a rulebook for what your insurance company will and won’t pay for. Most standard policies are designed to handle sudden and accidental damage, but the details can get tricky. Taking some time to review your documents helps you spot potential gaps in your coverage and make sure you have the protection you actually need for your home and belongings.

The Basics of Standard Coverage

Your standard homeowners insurance policy is there to protect you from sudden, unexpected events. Think of things like a pipe bursting, a kitchen fire, or a tree falling on your roof during a storm. The key words here are “sudden” and “accidental.” Insurance is designed to cover these unforeseen disasters, not issues that arise from a lack of maintenance or general wear and tear over time. So, while it might cover the water damage from that burst pipe, it likely won’t cover a slow leak you’ve known about for months.

What Your Policy Likely Excludes

It’s just as important to know what your policy doesn’t cover. As mentioned, problems that result from neglect or normal aging aren’t typically included. For example, if your roof is 25 years old and starts leaking simply because it’s worn out, your policy probably won’t pay for a replacement. The same goes for mold caused by a persistent leak you didn’t fix or a foundation crack that developed slowly over years. Your insurance company expects you to keep up with regular home maintenance to prevent these kinds of issues from happening in the first place.

Florida-Specific Policy Details to Know

Living in Florida comes with its own unique set of risks, and your insurance policy reflects that. One of the most critical things to understand is that standard homeowners insurance policies do not cover flood damage. Whether you’re in a high-risk zone or not, damage from rising water caused by heavy rain or storm surge requires a separate flood insurance policy. Given our state’s weather patterns, this is a piece of coverage every homeowner should seriously consider. Don’t wait until a storm is on the way to find out you’re not protected.

Protecting Your High-Value Items

Many people are surprised to learn that their policy has coverage limits on certain high-value personal belongings. While your insurance might cover the theft of your laptop, it may not cover the full value of expensive jewelry, art, fine china, or special collections. Most policies have a cap—say, $1,500—for items like these. If your wedding ring or coin collection is worth more than that, you would only be reimbursed for the maximum amount listed in your policy. It’s a common myth that everything inside your home is fully covered, no matter its value.

When to Consider Extra Coverage

If you’ve identified gaps in your standard policy, it might be time to look into extra coverage. You can often add a “rider” or “floater” to your existing policy to insure specific high-value items for their full appraised value. This gives you peace of mind that your most precious belongings are protected. Similarly, if you run a business from home or live in an area prone to specific events not covered by a standard policy, you may need to purchase separate, specialized insurance. Reviewing your needs with an agent can help you build a more complete protection plan.

How to Protect Your Property and Prevent Claims

While you can’t predict every accident, taking proactive steps to maintain your property can make a huge difference. A little prevention can save you from the stress and expense of filing a claim. By focusing on a few key areas, you can significantly reduce the risk of common types of damage and keep your home safe.

Prevent Water Damage

Water damage can be sneaky and destructive, but a few simple habits can help keep your home dry. If you’re heading out of town for more than a couple of days, it’s a good practice to turn off your home’s main water supply. During colder months, keeping your thermostat at 55 degrees or higher can prevent pipes from freezing and bursting. It’s also wise to periodically check that your sump pump is working correctly, especially before a heavy rainstorm. These small actions can help you avoid some of the most common and costly water damage claims that property owners face.

Improve Your Home’s Fire Safety

Making fire safety a part of your routine is one of the best ways to protect your home and family. Simple things, like never leaving a lit candle unattended and double-checking that your stove is off after cooking, can prevent a disaster. Another easy but crucial task is cleaning the lint trap in your dryer after every single load, as lint buildup is highly flammable. You should also get into the habit of testing your smoke alarms monthly and swapping out the batteries twice a year. These consistent checks ensure your first line of defense is always ready.

Prepare for Storm Season

Living in Florida means preparing for storm season is non-negotiable. Wind and hail are responsible for a huge percentage of home insurance claims, so getting your property ready is essential. Before a storm hits, take time to secure loose items in your yard, like patio furniture and grills, that could become projectiles in high winds. Inspecting your roof for loose shingles and ensuring your windows and doors have a proper seal can also prevent significant damage. Having a solid hurricane preparedness plan in place doesn’t just protect your property; it provides peace of mind when the weather takes a turn.

Secure Your Home from Theft

Protecting your home from theft involves both physical security and being mindful of your digital footprint. It’s a good idea to avoid posting vacation plans or sharing photos on social media while you’re still away, as this can alert potential burglars that your home is empty. On the physical front, installing a home security system can be a powerful deterrent. Even simple measures like adding motion-activated lights near all your exterior doors can make your home a less appealing target. These layers of security work together to keep your property and belongings safe whether you’re home or away.

Follow a Regular Maintenance Schedule

Consistent home maintenance is your best defense against unexpected problems. Think of it as a regular health check-up for your house. Periodically inspecting your roof, plumbing, siding, and fences allows you to catch small issues before they become major, expensive repairs. For example, fixing a small leak in your roof is much easier than dealing with the extensive water damage it could cause over time. Keeping up with these tasks not only prevents claims but also shows your insurance provider that you’re a responsible homeowner, which can be beneficial if you ever do need to file a claim.

A Smart Guide to Filing Your Insurance Claim

Dealing with property damage is stressful enough without having to figure out the complexities of an insurance claim. The process can feel overwhelming, but taking a methodical approach can make a significant difference in the outcome. Think of it as a series of manageable steps that put you in a better position to get the fair settlement you deserve. By being prepared and knowing what to expect, you can handle the process with confidence.

Document Everything Correctly

Before you move a single thing, your first job is to become a detective. Grab your phone and start taking photos and videos of all the damage. The more detailed you are, the better. Capture wide shots of the affected rooms and close-ups of specific damage. Don’t forget to document the source of the problem if you can, like a burst pipe or a hole in the roof. It’s also a good idea to create an inventory of damaged items. Keep any ruined belongings until your insurance adjuster has seen them and gives you the green light to dispose of them. This evidence is crucial for building a strong claim.

Decide When It’s Time to File

Not every incident of damage warrants an insurance claim. A good rule of thumb is to consider filing only if the cost of repairs is significantly more than your policy’s deductible. Your deductible is the amount you have to pay out of pocket before your insurance coverage kicks in. If the repair cost is only slightly above your deductible, you might want to handle it yourself. Filing claims, especially smaller ones, can sometimes lead to an increase in your insurance rates over time. Carefully weighing the costs against your deductible can help you make a smart financial decision for the long run.

How a Public Adjuster Can Help

When the damage is extensive and the stakes are high, the claims process can feel like a full-time job. This is where a public adjuster can be an invaluable ally. Unlike the adjuster sent by your insurance company, a public adjuster works directly for you, the policyholder. Their job is to manage the entire claims process on your behalf—from documenting the loss to negotiating with the insurer. At PA Joe, we are public adjusters who advocate for homeowners to ensure they receive the maximum fair settlement they’re entitled to. We handle the headaches so you can focus on getting your property—and your life—back in order.

Tips for a Fair Settlement

To ensure you’re on a level playing field with your insurance company, it helps to do your own homework. One of the most effective steps you can take is to get written estimates from a few reputable, local contractors for the repair work. This gives you a realistic, independent assessment of the costs, which you can use as a benchmark when reviewing the insurance company’s settlement offer. Having these figures in hand provides you with concrete evidence to support your claim and is a powerful tool during negotiations. It shows the insurer that you’ve done your research and understand the true cost of restoring your property.

Avoid These Common Filing Mistakes

A couple of common misunderstandings can trip up homeowners during the claims process. First, many assume their standard policy covers every single thing they own, but that’s often not the case. Policies have limits, especially for high-value items like jewelry or art, and may not cover all your personal belongings without extra coverage. Another myth is that your insurer can’t raise your rates after a single claim. While they might not cancel your policy for one claim, they can—and often do—increase your premium at renewal time. Understanding the fine print of your policy helps you avoid these pitfalls and set realistic expectations.

What to Expect After You File a Claim

Filing an insurance claim can feel like stepping into the unknown. Once you’ve notified your insurance company, a new phase begins, one filled with paperwork, inspections, and negotiations. Understanding this process can make it feel much more manageable and put you in a better position to get the settlement you deserve. The journey from filing to final payment involves several key stages, each with its own set of expectations and potential challenges. Knowing what’s ahead helps you prepare, gather the right information, and advocate for yourself effectively. Let’s walk through what typically happens after you submit your claim.

Your First Steps After Damage Occurs

After you’ve taken immediate steps to prevent further damage—like placing a tarp over a hole in the roof—your next call is to your insurance company to start the claims process. This officially begins your request for reimbursement for the losses you’ve sustained. An adjuster from your insurance company will be assigned to your case and will likely contact you to schedule an inspection. This initial period is critical for setting the tone for your entire claim. It’s important to be organized and responsive, but remember that the insurance company’s adjuster is there to represent their interests, not necessarily yours.

The Paperwork You’ll Need

Solid documentation is the foundation of a strong claim. Your insurance company will need proof of the damage and the value of your losses. Start by taking extensive photos and videos of everything that was affected, from structural damage to personal belongings. Don’t throw anything away until your claim is settled, as the adjuster may need to see the damaged items. It’s also a great idea to get written repair estimates from a trusted local contractor. Keeping a detailed log of every conversation with your insurance company, including dates, times, and topics discussed, will also be incredibly helpful as you move forward with a water damage claim or any other type of loss.

How Long Will the Process Take?

The timeline for an insurance claim can vary widely. While some straightforward claims might be resolved in a couple of weeks, many others take much longer. The complexity of the damage, the thoroughness of your documentation, and your insurance company’s internal processes all play a role. A major fire claim, for example, will naturally take more time to assess than a minor leak. Delays can happen if there are disagreements about the scope of the damage or the cost of repairs. Patience is key, but so is persistence. Following up regularly and providing any requested information promptly can help keep the process moving.

The Negotiation Phase

Once the insurance company’s adjuster has inspected the damage, they will prepare a report and present you with a settlement offer. It’s possible this initial offer may be lower than what you need to fully recover. This is where negotiation begins. You have the right to review their assessment and present your own evidence, like your contractor’s estimates, to justify a higher amount. Remember, it’s generally best to file a claim only when the repair costs are significantly more than your deductible. The goal of the negotiation is to reach an agreement that fairly covers those costs. Having an expert from a firm like PA Joe on your side can make a huge difference in these discussions.

How a Claim Might Affect Future Coverage

It’s a common concern: will filing a claim make my insurance rates go up? The short answer is that it might. Filing a claim, especially for certain types of damage, can lead to an increase in your premium at renewal time. In some cases, filing multiple claims within a few years could even result in your insurer choosing not to renew your policy. This shouldn’t discourage you from filing a necessary claim for significant damage—that’s what insurance is for. However, it does highlight the importance of being strategic and handling smaller repairs out-of-pocket if the cost isn’t much higher than your deductible.

Related Articles

• Homeowner coverage – Public Adjuster
• Does Homeowners Insurance Cover Water Line Replacement? – Public Adjuster
• Does Homeowners Insurance Cover Vandalism? What to Know – Public Adjuster

Frequently Asked Questions

Should I file a claim for minor damage? This is a great question, and the answer really depends on your specific situation. A good starting point is to compare the estimated cost of repairs to your insurance deductible. If the repair cost is only slightly higher than what you’d have to pay out-of-pocket anyway, it might make more sense to handle it yourself. Filing claims, particularly smaller ones, can sometimes lead to an increase in your premium when it’s time to renew your policy, so it’s worth weighing the immediate savings against the potential long-term cost.

What’s the real difference between the insurance company’s adjuster and a public adjuster? It’s easy to get these two confused, but they have very different roles. The adjuster sent by your insurance company works for them. Their job is to assess the damage on behalf of the insurer. A public adjuster, on the other hand, is someone you hire to work for you. They advocate on your behalf, managing the entire claims process from documentation to negotiation, with the goal of making sure you receive a fair and complete settlement.

How can I prove what my belongings were worth after they’ve been damaged? This is where being proactive can make a huge difference. The best way to prepare for this is to create a home inventory before you ever need one. You can do this by walking through your home and taking a video of your belongings, or by creating a list with photos and noting purchase dates and prices for major items. If you do experience a loss, this documentation becomes invaluable proof for your claim, making the process much smoother.

What should I do if my insurance company’s settlement offer seems too low? It’s important to remember that an initial settlement offer is just that—an offer. It’s not necessarily the final word. If the amount seems too low to cover your repairs, you have the right to negotiate. A powerful step is to get your own independent repair estimates from reputable local contractors. This provides you with concrete evidence to support your position and helps you build a strong case for a more appropriate settlement amount.

What are my options if my claim gets denied? Receiving a denial letter can feel defeating, but it doesn’t always have to be the end of the road. First, carefully read the denial letter to understand the specific reason your insurer gave. Policies can be complex, and sometimes claims are denied based on a misunderstanding of the damage or a detail in the fine print. You may have the option to appeal the decision or provide additional information. This is also a point where seeking a second opinion from a professional, like a public adjuster, could help you understand if you have grounds to contest the denial.